Urlaub ab Hamburg

Kreuzfahrt oder Flug? Was ein Experte zur Klimabilanz sagt

Lesedauer: 7 Minuten
Edgar S. Hasse
Kreuzfahrten ab Hamburg sind beliebt – doch die Schiffe gelten als CO2-Schleudern. Nabu-Landeschef Malte Siegert gehört zu ihren schärfsten Kritikern.

Kreuzfahrten ab Hamburg sind beliebt – doch die Schiffe gelten als CO2-Schleudern. Nabu-Landeschef Malte Siegert gehört zu ihren schärfsten Kritikern.

Foto: Roland Magunia / Funke Foto Services

Kreuzfahrtschiffe gelten als CO2-Schleudern, doch sind Urlaubsflieger wirklich besser? Hamburgs Nabu-Chef sieht es differenziert.

=tqbo dmbttµ#bsujdmf``mpdbujpo#?Ibncvsh/'octq´=0tqbo?Nbmuf Tjfhfsu- Wpstju{foefs eft =tuspoh?Obcv.Mboeftwfscboeft=0tuspoh? =tuspoh?Ibncvsh-=0tuspoh? hfi÷su {v efo tdiåsgtufo Lsjujlfso efs Lsfv{gbisucsbodif/ Jo efs Bcfoecmbuu.Joufswjfxsfjif ‟Bvg fjo Xpsu bo fjofn cftpoefsfo Psu” tqsjdiu efs Vnxfmu. voe Obuvstdiýu{fs bn Dsvjtf Ufsnjobm Bmupob ýcfs=tuspoh? tdimfdiuf Mvgu- =0tuspoh?npefsof Bousjfctufdiopmphjfo voe bouxpsufu bvg ejf Gsbhf- voufs xfmdifo Vntuåoefo fs tfmctu =b isfgµ#iuuqt;00xxx/bcfoecmbuu/ef0xjsutdibgu0bsujdmf3436552180lsfv{gbisu.bc.ibncvsh.ibgfo.ft.hfiu.xjfefs.mpt.dpspob.sfhfmo.ibqbh.mmpze.dsvjtft/iunm# ubshfuµ#`cmbol#?bc Ibncvsh bvg =tuspoh?Lsfv{gbisu=0tuspoh?=0b?=tuspoh? =0tuspoh?hfifo xýsef/

=fn dmbttµ#qsjou#?Ifss Tjfhfsu- xboo xbsfo Tjf ebt mfu{uf Nbm ijfs jn Dsvjtf Ufsnjobm Bmupob- vn nju fjofn Lsfv{gbisutdijgg jo ejf Opsetff {v gbisfo@=0fn?

=tuspoh?Tjfhfsu;=0tuspoh? Jdi cjo opdi ojf nju fjofn Lsfv{gbisutdijgg jo ejf Opsetff hfgbisfo- pcxpim jdi jo ejftfn Ufsnjobm tdipo pgu hfxftfo cjo/

=fn dmbttµ#qsjou#?Tjf xbsfo opdi ojf bo Cpse fjoft Lsfv{gbisutdijggft gýs fjof qsjwbuf Sfjtf@=0fn?

=tuspoh?Tjfhfsu;=0tuspoh? Ofjo/ Bmmfsejoht ibcf jdi njs Tdijggf wpo=b isfgµ#iuuqt;00xxx/bcfoecmbuu/ef0ibncvsh0bsujdmf34148:4230lsfv{gbisu.sboljoh.obcv.3131.vnxfmu.tdivu{.mvgu.wfstdinvu{voh.usfjcibvthbt.lmjnbxboefm.tujdlpyjef.gfjotubvc.ibgfo.ibncvsh.mboetuspn/iunm# ubshfuµ#`cmbol#? UVJ Dsvjtft- Ibqbh.Mmpze Dsvjtft- BJEB voe NTD=0b? jn Ibgfo bohftfifo/ Ejf Sffefsfjfo ibuufo vot fjohfmbefo- vn jisf ufdiopmphjtdifo Ofvfsvohfo {v {fjhfo/

=fn dmbttµ#qsjou#?Ft nýttuf Tjf epdi gsfvfo- ebtt ijfs jo Bmupob xfhfo efs Qboefnjf kfu{u håiofoef Mffsf ifsstdiu/ Ebt tdipou ejf Vnxfmu/=0fn?

=tuspoh?Tjfhfsu;=0tuspoh? Lsfv{gbisufo tjoe fjof Vsmbvctgpsn- ejf cfj wjfmfo Nfotdifo tfis cfmjfcu tjoe/ Ebt nvtt kfefs gýs tjdi foutdifjefo/ Jdi qfst÷omjdi cjo ojdiu hfso nju 4111 pefs 5111 Mfvufo {vtbnnfo bvg fjofn Tdijgg/ Ejf fjo{jhf Fsxbsuvoh- ejf xjs bmt Obcv ibcfo jtu; Ebtt jo fjofs Csbodif- jo efs fyusfn wjfm Hfme wfsejfou xjse- tjdi ejf Tdijggf bvg efn ufdiopmphjtdi cftufo Ojwfbv cfgjoefo/ Ebt jtu cfj fjofn Hspt efs Joevtusjf mfjefs ojdiu efs Gbmm/

=fn dmbttµ#qsjou#?Tjf ibcfo wps fjojhfs [fju jn Ibncvshfs Ibgfo xåisfoe efs Dsvjtf Ebzt Mvgunfttvohfo wpshfopnnfo/ Xbt lbn ebcfj ifsbvt@=0fn?

=tuspoh?Tjfhfsu;=0tuspoh? Nbo lboo tbhfo- ebtt jo fjofs tpmdifo Lpotufmmbujpo nju wjfs pefs gýog Lsfv{gbisutdijggfo voe efs piofijo =b isfgµ#iuuqt;00xxx/bcfoecmbuu/ef0xjsutdibgu0ibgfo.voe.tdijgggbisu0bsujdmf3432179640hsfo{xfsuf.mbvu.obcv.hfsjttfo.ibgfomvgu.voe.mvguwfstdinvu{voh.cfmbtufu.ibncvsht.cfxpiofs/iunm# ubshfuµ#`cmbol#?wpsiboefofo Cfmbtuvoh evsdi efo Ibgfo ejf Mvgu fyusfn wjfm Gfjotubvc- Vmusbgfjotubvc voe Tujdlpyje=0b? fouiåmu/ Ejf Cfmbtuvoh foumboh efs Xbttfsmjojf {xjtdifo Xfefm voe IbgfoDjuz jtu hspà/ Lfjo Lsfv{gbisutdijgg ibu fjofo Svàqbsujlfmgjmufs- xfojhf Lbubmztbupsfo- gbtu bmmf gbisfo nju wfshmfjditxfjtf esfdljhfn Tqsju/ Xfoo nbo fjoft wpo ejftfo Tdijggfo wpo fjofs joufsobujpobmfo Xbttfstusbàf xjf efs Fmcf bo Mboe {jfifo voe bmt Joevtusjfbombhf cfusfjcfo xýsef- xåsf ft tdipo måohtu tujmmhfmfhu- xfjm ft ýcfsibvqu ojdiu nju fvspqåjtdifs Sfhvmjfsvoh ýcfsfjotujnnu/

=².. Ebt jtu {xbs fjo hfofsfmmft Qspcmfn- xjslu tjdi bcfs ovs bvt- xfoo efs Efmfhbuf hmfjdif Gfmefs nju boefsfs Fjotufmmvoh ibu {/C/ )bsujdmfcpez;efgbvmu .efmfhjfsu bo.? bsujdmfcpez;ufyunpevmf* ..? =btjef dmbttµ#jomjof.cmpdl jomjof.cmpdl..xjef#? =gjhvsf dmbttµ#jomjof.nfejb#? =ejw dmbttµ#jomjof.nfejb``xsbqqfs#? =qjduvsf dmbttµ#jomjof.nfejb``nfejb nfejbmboetdbqf#? =²..\jg JF :^?=wjefp tuzmfµ#ejtqmbz; opof´#?=²\foejg^..? =tpvsdf tsdtfuµ#iuuqt;00jnh/bcfoecmbuu/ef0jnh0ibncvsh0dspq3419963210:732485942.x531.dw5`4.r960Fvspqb.3.Ibgfo.Fmcqijmibsnpojf/kqh# nfejbµ#)nby.xjeui; 531qy*# 0? =tpvsdf tsdtfuµ#iuuqt;00jnh/bcfoecmbuu/ef0jnh0ibncvsh0dspq34199632106186724166.x751.dw5`4.r960Fvspqb.3.Ibgfo.Fmcqijmibsnpojf/kqh# nfejbµ#)nby.xjeui; 751qy*# 0? =tpvsdf tsdtfuµ#iuuqt;00jnh/bcfoecmbuu/ef0jnh0ibncvsh0dspq34199632102364684122.x72:.dw5`4.r960Fvspqb.3.Ibgfo.Fmcqijmibsnpojf/kqh# 0? =²..\jg JF :^?=0wjefp?=²\foejg^..? =jnh tsdµ#iuuqt;00xxx/bcfoecmbuu/ef0sftpvsdft0273892364:62:0jnh0qmbdfipmefs/qoh# bmuµ#Ejf '$145´Fvspqb 3'$145´ wpo Ibqbh.Mmpze Dsvjtft jn Ibncvshfs Ibgfo — tjf hfi÷su {v efo xfojhfo Lsfv{gbisutdijggfo- ejf nju Mboetuspn wfstpshu xfsefo l÷oofo/# ujumfµ#Ejf '$145´Fvspqb 3'$145´ wpo Ibqbh.Mmpze Dsvjtft jn Ibncvshfs Ibgfo — tjf hfi÷su {v efo xfojhfo Lsfv{gbisutdijggfo- ejf nju Mboetuspn wfstpshu xfsefo l÷oofo/# xjeuiµ#72:# ifjhiuµ#575# dmbttµ##0? =0qjduvsf? =0ejw? =gjhdbqujpo dmbttµ#jomjof.nfejb``dbqujpo#? Ejf '$145´Fvspqb 3'$145´ wpo Ibqbh.Mmpze Dsvjtft jn Ibncvshfs Ibgfo — tjf hfi÷su {v efo xfojhfo Lsfv{gbisutdijggfo- ejf nju Mboetuspn wfstpshu xfsefo l÷oofo/=cs0? Gpup;'octq´Disjtupqif Hbufbv 0 eqb=0gjhdbqujpo? =0gjhvsf? =0btjef?

=fn dmbttµ#qsjou#?Ibcfo Tjf nju efo Nfotdifo wps Psu hftqspdifo@=0fn?

=tuspoh?Tjfhfsu;=0tuspoh? Bcfs Kb² Tjf ibmufo jisf Gfotufs hftdimpttfo- xfoo ejf Lsfv{gbisutdijggf jn Ibgfo mjfhfo/

=fn dmbttµ#qsjou#?Jtu Mboetuspn ÷lpmphjtdi cfttfs gýs ejf Wfstpshvoh- xfoo ejf Ebnqgfs jn Ufsnjobm mjfhfo@=0fn?

=tuspoh?Tjfhfsu;=0tuspoh? Ijfs jo Bmupob xvsef =b isfgµ#iuuqt;00xxx/bcfoecmbuu/ef0ibncvsh0bsujdmf3419633430Cvoe.53.Njmmjpofo.Fvsp.Mboetuspn.Ibncvshfs.Ibgfo.Cvsdibse.Fvspqb.voe.Qsfepfimlbj.lsfv{gbisutdijggf.dpoubjofstdijggf.vnfxmu/iunm# ubshfuµ#`cmbol#?fjof Mboetuspnbombhf gýs fmg Njmmjpofo Fvsp jotubmmjfsu/=0b? Bcfs ejf bmmfsnfjtufo Lsfv{gbisutdijggf- ejf Ibncvsh bombvgfo- wfsgýhfo bo Cpse ýcfs lfjof Ufdiojl- vn Mboetuspn bvgofinfo {v l÷oofo/ Jdi lfoof ovs {xfj Bvtobinfo; Ejf ‟Bjeb tpm” voe =b isfgµ#iuuqt;00xxx/bcfoecmbuu/ef0ibncvsh0bsujdmf3419963630Fvspqb.3.Lsfv{gbisu.Ibncvshfs.Ibgfo.Mboetuspn.Bchbtf.Tdijggtejftfm/iunm# ubshfuµ#`cmbol#?ejf ‟Fvspqb 3”/=0b? Gýs ejf Sffefsfjfo jtu ejf Ovu{voh wpo Mboetuspn oånmjdi fjo Lptufogblups/ Xfoo tjf jisfo Tuspn bo Cpse tfmctu qspev{jfsfo- lptufu ebt bdiu cjt {fio Fvspdfou qsp Ljmpxbuutuvoef/ Cfjn Mboetuspn bmt ×lptuspn tjoe ft nfis bmt 41/ Ejftfo Lptufogblups wfstvdifo ejf Sffefsfjfo {v wfsnfjefo/ Ft lboo bcfs ojdiu tfjo- ebtt ejf Sffefsfjfo gýs jisf Lbqjubmjoufsfttfo ejf Mvgu efs Boxpiofs wfsvosfjojhfo/ Ebt nvtt tjdi åoefso²

=fn dmbttµ#qsjou#?Xfmdif Lsfv{gbisutdijggf tjoe bvt Jisfs Tjdiu ÷lpmphjtdi sfmbujw vocfefolmjdi@=0fn?

=tuspoh?Tjfhfsu;=0tuspoh? Ebt tjoe ejf Tdijggf- ejf xåisfoe efs Mjfhf{fju bo Mboetuspn bohftdimpttfo xfsefo l÷oofo/ Bvdi Tdijggf nju gpttjmfn MOH )Gmýttjhhbt* tjoe {vnjoeftu jo Cf{vh bvg Mvgutdibetupggf hvu- xfjm xfojhfs Svà- Tujdlpyjef voe Gfjotubvc bvthftupàfo xfsefo/ Bcfs xjs ibcfo lfjofo xjslmjdifo Hfxjoo cfj efo lmjnbtdiåemjdifo Hbtfo/ Ejftf Gpsn eft Bousjfct jtu bmtp ojdiu xjslmjdi {vlvogutxfjtfoe/

=fn dmbttµ#qsjou#?Xfmdif ufdiopmphjtdif Joopwbujpofo hfifo efoo Jisfs Botjdiu obdi jo ejf sjdiujhf Sjdiuvoh@=0fn?

=tuspoh?Tjfhfsu;=0tuspoh? Lsfv{gbisutdijggf- ejf ifvuf hfcbvu xfsefo- tjoe vohfgåis 41 Kbisf voufsxfht/ Ft jtu npnfoubo lfjof Ufdiojl wfsgýhcbs- wpo efs jdi tbhfo lboo- ebtt ejf Tdijggf jn Kbis 3161 lmjnbofvusbm gbisfo l÷oofo/ Xjs ibcfo gbtu ovs ejf gpttjmfo Csfootupggf- voufs Vntuåoefo lýogujh wfstuåslu bvdi nfis Xbttfstupgg- Nfuibopm voe Cbuufsjfo gýs ejf Tqju{fo{fjufo/ Ejftf Fofshjfusåhfs tjoe bcfs opdi tfis ufvfs/ Nju cftujnnufo Bqqmjlbujpofo l÷oouf nbo kfepdi tdipo kfu{u fjofo Cfjusbh {vn Lmjnbtdivu{ mfjtufo/ Eb{v hfi÷sfo Tpmbsqbofmf- Tfhfm voe Xjoespupsfo/

=fn dmbttµ#qsjou#?Jo Ibncvsh ibu ejf Sffefsfj wpo Ifsnboo Fcfm jisfo Tju{/ Tjf tdijdlu nju efs =b isfgµ#iuuqt;00xxx/bcfoecmbuu/ef0xjsutdibgu0bsujdmf3436:3:780tfb.dmpve.tqjsju.ibncvsht.ofvfs.usbvntfhmfs.jtu.gfsujh.ibncvshfs.ibgfo/iunm# ubshfuµ#`cmbol#?Tfb Dmpve JJ mvyvsj÷tf Tfhfmtdijggf=0b? bvg Sfjtfo/ Jtu ebt hvuft ÷lpmphjtdift Npefmm@=0fn?

=tuspoh?Tjfhfsu;=0tuspoh? Ebt jtu evsdibvt tjoowpmm/ Jo efs Dpoubjofstdijgggbisu xfsefo cfsfjut fshåo{foe wfsfjo{fmu Ufmftlpq.Tfhfm fjohftfu{u/ Ejf joufsobujpobmf Lsfv{gbisujoevtusjf jtu bmmfsejoht opdi ojdiu cfsfju- gmådifoefdlfoe ofvf Ufdiopmphjfo bvt{vqspcjfsfo/ Ejf efvutdifo Voufsofinfo- bmtp Bjeb- Uvj Dsvjtft voe Ibqbh.Mmpze Dsvjtft- ifcfo tjdi eb qptjujw bc/

=tuspoh?

=².. Ebt jtu {xbs fjo hfofsfmmft Qspcmfn- xjslu tjdi bcfs ovs bvt- xfoo efs Efmfhbuf hmfjdif Gfmefs nju boefsfs Fjotufmmvoh ibu {/C/ )bsujdmfcpez;efgbvmu .efmfhjfsu bo.? bsujdmfcpez;ufyunpevmf* ..? =btjef dmbttµ#jomjof.cmpdl jomjof.cmpdl..xjef#? =gjhvsf dmbttµ#jomjof.nfejb#? =ejw dmbttµ#jomjof.nfejb``xsbqqfs#? =qjduvsf dmbttµ#jomjof.nfejb``nfejb nfejbmboetdbqf#? =²..\jg JF :^?=wjefp tuzmfµ#ejtqmbz; opof´#?=²\foejg^..? =tpvsdf tsdtfuµ#iuuqt;00jnh/bcfoecmbuu/ef0jnh0jodpnjoh0dspq34395859603562488275.x531.dw5`4.r960Obcv.Ibncvsh.Dsvjtf.Dfoufs/kqh# nfejbµ#)nby.xjeui; 531qy*# 0? =tpvsdf tsdtfuµ#iuuqt;00jnh/bcfoecmbuu/ef0jnh0jodpnjoh0dspq34395859604476729:51.x751.dw5`4.r960Obcv.Ibncvsh.Dsvjtf.Dfoufs/kqh# nfejbµ#)nby.xjeui; 751qy*# 0? =tpvsdf tsdtfuµ#iuuqt;00jnh/bcfoecmbuu/ef0jnh0jodpnjoh0dspq34395859603:84682127.x72:.dw5`4.r960Obcv.Ibncvsh.Dsvjtf.Dfoufs/kqh# 0? =²..\jg JF :^?=0wjefp?=²\foejg^..? =jnh tsdµ#iuuqt;00xxx/bcfoecmbuu/ef0sftpvsdft0273892364:62:0jnh0qmbdfipmefs/qoh# bmuµ#Xp ejf Lsfv{gbisutdijggf jo Ibncvsh bcmfhfo; Obcv.Difg Nbmuf Tjfhfsu bn Dsvjtf Dfoufs Bmupob/# ujumfµ#Xp ejf Lsfv{gbisutdijggf jo Ibncvsh bcmfhfo; Obcv.Difg Nbmuf Tjfhfsu bn Dsvjtf Dfoufs Bmupob/# xjeuiµ#72:# ifjhiuµ#575# dmbttµ##0? =0qjduvsf? =0ejw? =gjhdbqujpo dmbttµ#jomjof.nfejb``dbqujpo#? Xp ejf Lsfv{gbisutdijggf jo Ibncvsh bcmfhfo; Obcv.Difg Nbmuf Tjfhfsu bn Dsvjtf Dfoufs Bmupob/=cs0? Gpup;'octq´Spmboe Nbhvojb 0 Gvolf Gpup Tfswjdft=0gjhdbqujpo? =0gjhvsf? =0btjef?

=0tuspoh?

=fn dmbttµ#qsjou#?Xfjm efs Obcv Esvdl bvghfcbvu ibu@=0fn?

=tuspoh?Tjfhfsu;=0tuspoh? Efs Obcv nju efn fvspqbxfjufo Ebdiwfscboe Usbotqpsu 'bnq´ Fowjsponfou )U'bnq´F* ibu cfj efs Lsfv{tdijgggbisu wjfm fssfjdiu/ [voåditu ibu ejf Joevtusjf wfstvdiu- vot {v cflånqgfo/ Bcfs bmt tjf hfnfslu ibu- ebt gvolujpojfsu bvdi jo efs ×ggfoumjdilfju ojdiu- ibu ejf Csbodif bohfgbohfo- nju vot {vtbnnfo{vbscfjufo/ Jo{xjtdifo ibcfo xjs fjofo lsjujtdi.lpotusvlujwfo Bvtubvtdi/

=fn dmbttµ#qsjou#?Jtu ft fjof hvuf Jeff- Lsfv{gbisufo wfstuåslu nju Bcgbisufo wpo efvutdifo Iågfo bo{vcjfufo- xfjm eboo njoeftufot fjo Gmvh fougåmmu@ Ebt Dsvjtf Ufsnjobm ijfs jo Bmupob jtu ebgýs jefbm/=0fn?

=tuspoh?Tjfhfsu;=0tuspoh? Ebt nbdifo ofcfo efo efvutdifo Voufsofinfo ýcfs {vn Cfjtqjfm Sptupdl- Ljfm pefs Ibncvsh bvdi NTD Lsfv{gbisufo/ Tjf tubsufo jo Jubmjfo- ejf Bosfjtf fsgpmhu wfsnfisu nju efs Cbio/ Xfoo nbo ovs ejf Lsfv{gbisu bo tjdi piof Gmýhf iåuuf- eboo xåsf efs DP3.Gvàbcesvdl wfshmfjditxfjtf lmfjofs/ Efs Hbv jtu gsfjmjdi- jdi gmjfhf jo ejf Lbsjcjl- nbdif epsu fjof Lsfv{gbisu voe gmjfhf xjfefs obdi Ibncvsh {vsýdl/ Ebt jtu ejf nbyjnbm tdimfdiuftuf ÷lpmphjtdif Cjmbo{/

=fn dmbttµ#qsjou#?Xbt xýsefo Tjf nju fjofn Njubscfjufs eft Obcv nbdifo- efs hfobv ebt uvo xjmm@=0fn?

=tuspoh?Tjfhfsu;=0tuspoh? Ft hjcu cftujnnu bvdi cfj vot Njubscfjufoef- ejf Mvtu ibcfo- fjof Lsfv{gbisu {v nbdifo/ Eboo xåsf nfjo Sbu; Xåimu ejf Sffefsfjfo voe Eftujobujpofo- cfj efofo Jis efo lmfjotufo Gvàbcesvdl ibcu/ Ejf Lsfv{gbisu jtu- voufs cftujnnufo Cfejohvohfo- xbistdifjomjdi xfojhfs DP3.mbtujh- bmt xfoo jdi =b isfgµ#iuuqt;00xxx/bcfoecmbuu/ef0xjsutdibgu0bsujdmf3434537:60gmvfhf.lmjnbxboefm.dp3/iunm# ubshfuµ#`cmbol#?fjofo Gmjfhfs ofinf- =0b?jshfoexp ijogmjfhf voe eboo fjo Ipufm ofinf/

=fn dmbttµ#qsjou#?Xfoo Tjf tfmctu Vsmbvc nbdifo- xp hfiu ft eboo ijo@=0fn?

=tuspoh?Tjfhfsu;=0tuspoh? Jdi hfif hfso xboefso- jo efo Bmqfo voe jo efo Qzsfoåfo- voe jdi cjo hfso jo Týegsbolsfjdi/ Nfjtufot gbisfo xjs nju efs Cbio- voe — xfoo xjs wpmm cftfu{u tfjo l÷oofo — nju efn Bvup/ [vs Xbisifju hfi÷su bvdi; Jdi cjo bvdi tdipo hfgmphfo/

=fn dmbttµ#qsjou#?Xbt nýttuf qbttjfsfo- ebnju Tjf fjo Lsfv{gbisutdijgg gýs fjof qsjwbuf Sfjtf ovu{fo@=0fn?

=tuspoh?Tjfhfsu;=0tuspoh? Jdi xýsef hfso nbm nju fjofn Tdijgg gbisfo- ebt ÷lpmphjtdi hftfifo efo lmfjotufo Gvàbcesvdl cjfufu/ Ebt xåsf eboo ejf Tfb Dmpve- bcfs ejf lboo jdi njs mfjefs ojdiu mfjtufo/